Tag Archives: Patriotism

Pen to Flag

Of course, flags are historical artifacts and also sources; history has evolved as a discipline to consider material culture as well as texts. But what about a flag with writing on it? That’s like a doubly powerful source, a testament to the era but also to the personal beliefs or acts of a particular person who lived in said era. This occurred to me when I looked (longer) at a Salem parade flag from the later nineteenth century; it was an auction lot a few years earlier, but now it’s on the market again, and suddenly it looked more interesting to me.

And here it is, at Jeff R. Bridgman American Antiques, the place to go if you’re interested in antique American flags. Bridgman not only has great stock, but offers up his considerable knowledge of antique flags so you can really learn a lot by just reading his descriptions. This particular flag is described as an antique American flag with 13 stars arranged in a 6-pointed great star/star of David pattern, of a type made for the 1876 Centennial of American Independence, worn and hand-inscribed by the owner in 1896, in Salem, Massachusetts, in celebration of the victory of Republican President-elect William McKinley; illustrated in “The Stars & the Stripes: Fabric of the American Spirit” by Richard Pierce (2005). So quite a famous, published flag. And here’s the writing: Worn Nov. 6, 1896. At the Prade in Salem to celebrate the Republican Victory. Josh rode Baby (a horse I presume) in this parade. McKinley and Gold. Wolcott Governor. 

The flag was “worn,” not carried. Josh rode Baby! So personal. It occurs to me that people felt differently about flags in the past: they wore them, cut them up and made mementos, wrote on them, kept them close, saved scraps. I have a family flag from the very same year (so inscribed) which I do keep close, but I would never wear it or write on it. I drape it from a window from time to time but that’s about it. I found more inscribed flags, all very evocative of their eras. I’m including some stamped (?) campaign flag below, probabaly a whole new “medium,” but the writing seems more powerful in its personal testimony.

Lincoln and Hamlin Campaign Parade Flag, 1860s, Freeman's Auctions

Freeman’s Auctions

           

I can’t imagine anything more poignant than this Civil War flag above,  memorializing the death of a New York soldier at Andersonville: it’s a miracle it survived, but also an indication of its value.

What could be more American than a 48-star flag referencing fireworks and a baseball game in Maine on July 4, 1903 from Bonsell Americana?

Perhaps a flag commissioned by the Grand Army of the Republic to mark the heroism of the Massachusetts 54th at the Battle of Fort Wagner on its 50th anniversary, below.

Writing on a flag was obviously a way to mark (literally) a very notable occasion, as in the cases below: Armistice or “Victory Day” in Milwaukee, November 1918, and the death of President Roosevelt in April of 1945 (and Joe West, whoever he was, in the next year). The juxtaposition of relative mundane acts and notable event is quite striking in the first one! Both scribes seem to want to express their patriotism, and in a more permanent way than taking pen to paper.

Jeff R. Bridgman American Antiques

 


Personal Declarations

I would love to hear about Revolutionary exhibitions, programs and events sheduled for your area in this 250th anniversary year: 1776 is certainly alive and well in the Boston area! Since I’m on sabbatical, I’ve been able to attend quite a few happenings, and my favorite collaborative initiative is the Declarations Trail, on which four institutions, the Boston Athenaeum, the Massachusetts Historical Society, the Boston Public Library and Harvard University’s Houghton Library, have put more than a dozen copies of the Declaration of Independence on view, “originally created in different printings for different audiences” along with lots of other contextual objects. I’ve been to the first two exhibitions at the Athenaeum and MHS, and am looking forward to the opening of the last two later this spring.

Looking at, and thinking about, these paper Declarations has got me thinking about their popular and personal reception. I am very mindful of the words of historian J.L. Bell on his great blog Boston 1775: for the first generations of Americans it was a set of words, not an object they ever saw but at the same time, I know that one of the primary functions of print is to make things more permanent, and with tangible permanance comes possession as well as remembrance. Following that trail in my mind brought me to textile Declarations in general and Declaration handkerchiefs in particular–because there seems to have been a market for these words that you could literally put in your pocket. That market did not really develop until the first era of remembrance for the American Revolution—the 1820s, approaching its 50th anniversary with participants dying—but then it really took off. A great book (Threads of History. Americana Recorded on Cloth 1775 to the Present by Smithsonian curator Herbert R. Collins), an archived exhibition at the Museum of the American Revolution, and numerous auction archives introduced me to the copperplate-printed handkerchiefs produced by William Gillespie & Sons in Scotland for the American market beginning in 1821. Produced in blue, black and red colorways, there’s a blue one coming up at auction next week at Eldred’s Auctions, and this spectacular red textile was the banner lot at an important Sotheby’s auction in 2023. A black (more sepia) handkerchief was sold by Swann Auction Galleries in 2023, and the Yale University Art Gallery has a similar one, as well as a centennial quilt from fifty years later sewn around the same: what a perfect object linking two eras of patriotic remembrance.

Textiles seem less ephemeral than paper, so I assume that the Declaration handkerchiefs of the 1820s were in demand as commemorative items, but it’s important to remember that this was also an era that the Declaration was being issued as separate broadside for the first time too–it was evolving from words into an object which could take several forms. The motifs that were featured on these textiles, including the “chain” of states, big Revolutionary moments, and the founding fathers, will reappear again and again. Fifty years later, the Centennial will inspire another wave of patriotic production, but those objects will be more familiar than introductory.