The Salem visual vibe is darker now, and focused firmly on “Gothic” rather than Federal or Colonial, but the Witch City used to be pretty. I wrote the chapter on the Colonial Revival in our forthcoming book Salem’s Centuries. New Perspectives on the History of an Old American City (for which we have our cover, and a production schedule, and a publication date coming soon!), spotlighting four Salem “influencers” who emphasized the city’s beauty and craftsmanship through various cultural initiatives: Mary Harrod Northend, Frank Cousins, George Francis Dow and Caroline Emmerton. They were so successful that Salem coasted into a period of being known primarily for its architectural and aesthetic heritage that lasted well into the 1960s, an image that was sustained by the Essex Institute’s house museums and the very public battle over urban renewal. A succession of commercial and graphic artists celebrated Salem through their accessible imagery, and we see Salem grouped with Colonial Williamsburg, Historic Deerfield, Sturbridge Village, Mystic Seaport, and other traditional heritage destinations. In today’s competitive tourism realm Salem has pulled ahead of (or moved behind?) that pack by emphasizing horror over beauty, Gothic over Federal, and darkness over light. At least that’s the projection I see in so many shop windows and on so many websites, but I think I better do some more searching in the real world. There are also many AI images of a Salem that doesn’t even exist, a concocted Victorian-Gothic world with black cats and cute witches, but also church spires! Fantasy Salem is even more idealistic than what came before, depictions in color and black and white of well-manicured car-free streets and stately houses, a “city of treasures” according to Katharine Butler Hathaway.
Some of my favorite images of Salem from the 1920s to the 1960s: Felicie Waldo Howell’s “Spring on Chestnut Street” + various houses; shelter magazines LOVED Salem in the 1920s; Rudolph Ruzicka made several Salem prints; interior vignettes from House & Garden, June 1939;Chestnut Street scenes from Philip Kappel and Samuel Chamberlain; LOVE these notecards from Nantucket artist Ruth Haviland Sutton; the “Silent Traveler,” Chiang Yee’s view of the Custom House.
April 7th, 2025 at 8:39 am
I loved Samuel Chamberlain’s books. I even appeared in two of them! Once in Hamilton Hall and once on a friend’s tuna boat. Wish I could rememberwhich books they were!
April 7th, 2025 at 8:52 am
Oh I have those here—let me look!
April 7th, 2025 at 9:33 am
Such beautiful art!!! I am a big fan of Arthur Wesley Dow and wish I could see his works in person.
April 7th, 2025 at 11:48 am
Me too; lovely views of Ipswich.
April 7th, 2025 at 12:09 pm
Sad to see that the Salem that I knew while growing up there in the ’50’s and ’60’s, is now over run with people who have little or no appreciation for its classical beauty. There are some really weird looking folks skulking around there these days!
April 7th, 2025 at 12:38 pm
Well, there’s obviously a large demographic group looking for all things dark and gothic so I suppose it’s good for the local economy, though I do wonder if it’s a long-term strategy.
April 11th, 2025 at 12:37 pm
I have been musing on this subject myself as I go about the downtown areas on my walks. I so admire our diverse architecture that I’m biased when I see this consumer oriented culture filling in spaces and creating a very specific culture out of seemingly thin air- disconnected from the general population. Instead of coming up from within the community, it is being placed upon it. It can come across that our treasured downtown is for others, for part of the year.
Whereas I agree it is good for fall tourism, the places are pretty quiet the rest of the year. Our healthcare industry dwarfs tourism in revenue for the City, so it’s not the major revenue stream.
Wouldn’t a healthy economy be one that survives all year round? I’m not so sure going all in on this witch business is healthy for our community long-term. (Besides that they were not witches.) Having it be part of it is fine, but in our now Instagram oriented world, there may be a tipping point. Long-term plans should really focus on developing a holistic version of Salem moving forward.
April 11th, 2025 at 12:47 pm
Oh please read city leaders! I couldn’t agree more.